How Do You Know What You Actually Need When It Comes to Your Garage Door?
by Chad Pederson, Director of Operations & Field Services
Two recent calls, and why the answers weren’t the same
I’ve been doing this for close to twenty years. Thirty thousand service calls, give or take.
Here’s how I decide what to tell a homeowner. What would I do if this were my grandma calling?
That’s it. That’s the whole method. I’m not going to sell her things she doesn’t need to line my pockets, and I’m not going to sell you things you don’t need either.
Here are two calls that came in recently. They didn’t come out the same way, and that’s the point.
Carrie was told she needed three new doors
Carrie, a homeowner in Burnsville, had water damage in her garage. Another company came out and quoted her three brand new doors at about $2,000 apiece. Six thousand dollars. Openers on top of that would have run another $2,000.
Call it $8,000.
Here’s what she actually wanted. New garage door openers. Specifically, ones with Wi-Fi so she could open and close the doors from her phone.
That’s what we put in. LiftMaster Security+ 2.0 with myQ, around $2,000 installed.
The doors were fine.
Tom was told to repair a door he should have replaced
Tom, a homeowner in Chanhassen, had two garage doors. One was damaged.
The other company quoted a repair, and it was the same playbook: replace the springs, the cables, all the hardware. Close to $3,000.
Here’s the part that got me. At the end of all that, he’d still have a 25-year-old door with tears in it and dents in the panels.
We found the exact same make and model. New door, all new hardware, new warranty. About $2,500.
He spent $500 less than the repair quote and got a new door instead of an old one.
The pattern
Two calls. Carrie needed a different thing entirely than what she was quoted. Tom needed more, and it still cost less.
That’s not a sales strategy. That’s just looking at the door.
Both of those quotes came out of a sales approach we see all over this market. It is called good, better, best. Three options, priced so the middle one looks reasonable, and every one of them more than the homeowner actually needed.
It works because it feels like your decision. You picked it. But you’re picking from a menu somebody else built, and you called a garage door tech in the first place because you don’t know garage doors.
You wanted somebody to tell you what you need. Not hand you three ways to overspend.
About that warranty
Here’s the one I want homeowners to understand.
No warranty legitimately requires you to replace all your hardware. The only time you replace everything is when you’re getting a new door, and that comes with its own warranty anyway.
If somebody tells you your warranty depends on buying parts, they’re not being straight with you.
In twenty years I have never been to a door that needed all its hinges replaced. Never one that needed all its rollers replaced. They’ve never all been bad. It might be one roller out of ten. There’s no reason to spend $200 on all your rollers when you only need one.
For the record, ours is a 3-year parts and labor warranty, and we’ve been doing this since 1967. If one of my technicians got something wrong, we stand behind it whether that was one year ago or ten.
Two things worth asking any company that quotes you.
How long have you been in business? Garage door companies come and go. A lifetime warranty isn’t worth much from a company that won’t be here.
Will you give me a ballpark over the phone? If they won’t, that tells you something. A $29 service call isn’t a price. It’s a way to get in the door before the real number shows up.
When we come out, the service call covers the trip and a 23-point inspection of the door. Every hinge, every roller, every bearing, the springs, the opener, the safety eyes, the safety reverse. We look at all of it, whether or not you end up needing anything.
What this comes down to
Do your research on whoever you call.
And ask what it’s going to cost before they drive out. We’ll tell you.
